Sure! I would ask for a second opinion definitely.
It will put your mind at ease to know that you have looked at every possible option and even if you remain with surgeon 1, you will know in your heart that you went with that decision with every single bit of knowledge available and have made a fully informed decision.
Knowledge is power, get a second opinion.
I don't put much stock in 'keeping it local', I much prefer going for the best outcome regardless of geography.
My mom went to another country to have surgery with the surgeon who actually invented the procedure she was having.
Geography means nothing in the grand scheme of medical care (in my opinion).